Showing posts with label Sudan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sudan. Show all posts

Saturday, February 17, 2007

Human Compassion Surprisingly Limited, Study Finds

by Sara Goudarzi, for LiveScience Journal

SAN FRANCISCO—While a person's accidental death reported on the evening news can bring viewers to tears, mass killings reported as statistics fail to tickle human emotions, a new study finds.

The Internet and other modern communications bring atrocities such as killings in Darfur, Sudan* into homes and office cubicles. But knowledge of these events fails to motivate most to take action, said Paul Slovic, a University of Oregon researcher.

People typically react very strongly to one death but their emotions fade as the number of victims increase, Slovic reported here yesterday at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

"We go all out to save a single identified victim, be it a person or an animal, but as the numbers increase, we level off," Slovic said. "We don't feel any different to say 88 people dying than we do to 87. This is a disturbing model, because it means that lives are not equal, and that as problems become bigger we become insensitive to the prospect of additional deaths."

Human insensitivity to large-scale human suffering has been observed in the past century with genocides in Armenia, the Ukraine, Nazi Germany and Rwanda, among others.

"We have to understand what it is in our makeup—psychologically, socially, politically and institutionally—that has allowed genocide to go unabated for a century," Slovic said. "If we don't answer that question and use the answer to change things, we will see another century of horrible atrocities around the world."

Slovic previously studied this phenomenon by presenting photographs to a group of subjects. In the first photograph eight children needed $300,000 to receive medical attention in order to save their lives. In the next photograph, one child needed $300,000 for medical bills.

Most subjects were willing to donate to the one and not the group of children.

In his latest research, Slovic and colleagues showed three photos to participants: a starving African girl, a starving African boy and a photo of both of them together.

Participants felt equivalent amounts of sympathy for each child when viewed separately, but compassion levels declined when the children were viewed together.

"The studies ... suggest a disturbing psychological tendency," Slovic said. "Our capacity to feel is limited. Even at two, people start to lose it.”


________________


On the issue of genocide, I am a bit disturb by the fact that Shabra Shatila genocide was not even mentioned by the writer. Sure, the 'official' death toll (3500) is probably not as much as the Auschwitz's 'death toll'; and the researcher's background (i.e. non-muslim*) might account for her to be innocently unaware of the significance of the tragedy; but I am still quite adamant that the tragedy is somewhat worth mentioning in such credible journal. This is especially true considering the backlash involved around the world condemning and boycotting Israel and 'her' goods. Nonetheless in the current political viewing of the tragedy (i.e. after the Belgian court proceedings**), who can blame him.


________________

* I have my doubts about the situation in Sudan, as noted in a previous post

* Be aware that I am saying this without prejudice whatsoever. Just that the genocide is understandably more emotionally significant and takes more political influence among muslims.

** Belgian Court Proceeding - After the victims of the Rwandan Genocide won a legal case using a 1993 law, the victims of Shabra Shatila Massacre filed a lawsuit in Belgium against Ariel Sharon (then Israeli Prime Minister but was the Minister of Defence at the time of massacre). The Belgium Supreme Court in February 2003 ruled that there were vindication to bring Sharon and his 'comrades' to face the charges.

Unfortunately at the time, another case was brought forward against the former US President George Bush and Secretary of State (if I'm not mistaken) Colin Powell for war crimes during the first Gulf War. US argued against the validity of having proceedings of war crime committed elsewhere taking place in Belgian Supreme Court. The US pressured the Belgian government to revoke the jurisdiction and even pressured its European Allies to move NATO HQ away from Brussels.

As a result, the Belgian Parliment were forced to amend its law to require human rights complaints to only take place in Belgium given that a Belgian is involved. They also guaranteed diplomatic immunity for world leaders visiting the country.

Sunday, November 05, 2006

How Media Manipulates Stuffs - A Re-enlightenment

I would like to first of all congratulate my little bro. Saturday was his graduation day from MRSM Q-Ber :) Best of luck in your SPM! My prayers and papa's and mama's will always be with you! U'll ace them all insya Allah!


Darfur

I read an article in Epigram, UoB's official student mag on Darfur the other day. It was provocative I must say. Not because of the issue at hand (i.e. Darfur, which I already 'knew' about) but because of the 'side-issue' that accompanies it.

Darfur lately managed to make the headline for all the wrong reason. Genocides were said to happen as the Arab Janjaweed tribe were said to have slayed every single African in sight. There were refugee camps organized all over the country (the term being - Internally Displaced People, other common example would be the people in Palestine and Lebanon which was deprived of their own shelter), some even in neighbouring Chad, Ethiopia, Uganda, Kenya and few other countries. Rape, murder is a common happenings. In fact the article claimed that only women are brave enough to go out of the refugee camp and search for food. Why? Because women by nature have added value to themselves, 'for sexual pleasure' (I quote). Men were only worth dead.


What's worse is, the government of Sudan were said to supply ammunitions (and at times, manpower!) to wipe off the African tribe from the face of the earth!
To my ignorance at the time of reading the article, I thought Sudan is another small African country, size as well as economy-interest-wise. But the presence of a few thousands African Union peacekeepers to peacekeep in Darfur, a region as big as France, tells me quite a different story about the size of Sudan.

What about economy? Well, I am still at that stage a bit ignorant about Sudan's economy.
What is the side issue that interests me? It is the fact that the US of A and its allies are trying to rally UN peacekeepers into Sudan. Sudan rejected this proposal (which only came out 1 or 2 years ago) and compromised by having the AU peacekeepers instead. But they are not satisfied, they are still trying to push soldiers into Sudan. And to me (at this point in time) that proposal sounds sensible and unselfish enough (unlike some other peacekeeping and anti-terror proposals).

To my horror, China vetoed against the proposal!
I never heard China doing such things before and I said to myself, this awaken dragon is a mean one...

Two days later I discussed the issue with another medic. She's from Sudan, but lived in the UK all her life. Her parents are Sudanese but migrated to the UK even before she was born. She went back every now and then to visit her relatives and do the usual stuff when people went back somewhere.

And interestingly enough she has got different ideas about the happenings in Darfur. To her there is actually no big issue or genocide or whatever. In fact she said that not many people in Sudan actually think there is an ongoing genocide in Darfur. The so-called 'genocides' have been happening since the 1980s. It is nothing close to a genocide, but rather a simple conflict between two tribes in dispute of land for cattle and agriculture. Killings happen every now and then but nothing more than killings that happened in Malaysia and the UK. The only thing is, the killings were done by a member of a tribe on the other.


That's refreshing, and severely exposed my ignoramus status.


'Why then,' I asked, 'US said that UN peacekeepers are needed in Darfur?' Her answer was rather simple, 'Oil.' UN peacekeepers are actually not needed in Darfur. The fact of the matter is (according to her) rather the contrary; the USA was the one in need of UN peacekeeper in Darfur. Why did China veto against the proposal? Because China invested a lot on the newly found Sudanese oil. At this point, the jigsawed picture started to become whole for me.

This 'conflict' has been going on for eons (or rather 20 years) and went unnoticed by everyone. Who would be interested in a land dispute between a bunch of farmers, let alone the 'great' USA? And then not too many years ago someone found oil in Sudan. China won the right to invest for oil in Sudan (Petronas did manage to get a piece of the pie as well; but not Exxon and co., haha). USA were pissed and rallied their whole battalion of journalist to blow the conflict out of proportion. When it became a 'big enough deal', UN peacekeepers were proposed. Sudanese government were against it. China vetoed against it. The USA became more pissed and frustrated. Simplistic, yet that's the picture that I get from the two contradictory sources.


Did China do bad though? As in, investing in the Sudanese oil-industry? According to my friend, they did not. At this moment in time, Chinese were literally everywhere in the streets of Sudan. Some of them even married the locals. By investing in the oil-industry they actually did good for the country. Acutely enough, Sudan is now the 35th largest oil producer in the world. By comparison, Malaysia is the 25th and that took us years. Jobs are now in abundant. Unemployment in Sudan was high for decades, estimated to be 18.7% in 2002. Population below poverty line was a soaring 40% in 2004. So jobs are always welcomed in Sudan. Sudan's GDP was a skyhigh 8.0% in 2005, quite high to Malaysia's 5.2% (which was ironically enough the same as Israel's). In short, China did great, as far as this matter of Sudanese oil is concerned.


This enlightment (I hope) is a very enlightening one. The conclusion that I get from this short encounter is rather unrelated to the main issue. Mass media is a major player in shaping up world's view on a certain issue. For all we know, they could say that genocides happen in Malaysia and the world would still believe it. To be fair, IF this enlightening is a rather misdirected one (which I seriously doubt); probably the Sudanese people were misdirected by their government's media. Why I doubt that? I doubt there's even a proper mass media coverage in Sudan (despite the presence of radio and TV stations in Sudan). People simply can't afford them. Everything comes from first hand experience.


Sources: Epigram October 2006, CIA - The World Factbook, a friend (who should remain anonymous)
=)